Friday, September 25, 2009

Fears allayed over menopausal memory loss

Medical Tribune August 2009 P8
David Brill

Women who experience memory loss as they approach the menopause can be reassured that the problem is only temporary, say US researchers.

In a recent study of over 2,000 women, they found that verbal memory and processing speed appear to drop during perimenopause, but typically return to normal upon reaching postmenopause.

The findings confirm a problem which is reported by up to 60 percent of women but has been addressed by very few quantitative studies, say the authors. [Neurology 2009;72:1850-7]

Lead author of the Study of Women’s Health Across the Nation (SWAN) report, Dr. Gail Greendale, said that physicians can now use the findings to reassure concerned women and “validate their experience.”

“Women who are experiencing memory difficulties during the menopause transition often find this experience frightening. They do not know what to expect and worry that their memory will worsen over time,” said Greendale, of the David Geffen School of Medicine at the University of California, Los Angeles, US.

“The SWAN results provide women with a frame of reference … and show that the memory problems are temporary. Also, if women are having memory problems of a greater degree than that which we observed, then their physician should not ascribe the problem to menopause and should dig deeper,” she said.

The SWAN study involved 2,362 women with a mean age of 45.9. They were classified as premenopausal, perimenopausal or postmenopausal, and followed for 4 years with regular testing in domains of processing speed, verbal memory and working memory.

The decline in cognition over the menopause transition was particularly marked for processing speed: pre- and postmenopausal women showed significant improvements with repeated testing, whereas late perimenopausal women scored worse over time. A similar effect was seen for verbal memory, but there was no difference in working memory between groups.

The paper also points to cognitive benefits of early initiation of hormone therapy: women who had already begun therapy before their final menstruation scored 4 to 6 percent higher on tests than those with no prior therapy.

Estrogen has a range of effects on the brain and is thought to influence mood, higher cognitive function and motor skills. Estrogen receptor density is particularly high in the prefrontal cortex and hippocampus – hence it has been postulated that the fluctuation in estrogen levels during perimenopause could adversely influence brain function. [J Appl Physiol 2001;91:2785-801]

Only two previous longitudinal studies however have measured cognitive performance over the menopause transition, according to Greendale and colleagues. The more recent of the two, a study of 694 women from a rural community in Taiwan, found that verbal memory declined during the menopause transition. The other study found no cognitive effects of the transition on working memory or perceptual speed. [Maturitas 2006;53:447-53; Neurology 2003;61:801-6]

No comments: