Friday, January 30, 2009

Show me the money!

New Scientist 22nd December 2007
Link
David Brill

THREE years at university may have left your finances firmly in the red. If you are considering furthering your education, the thought of accumulating yet more debt can be a frightening prospect. But before you surrender your soul to the devil, it's worth considering that in 2006, the UK had 545,370 registered postgraduate students who, more than likely, obtained funding through more traditional routes.

"I find there's a lot of pessimism where there's no need for pessimism," says Duncan Connors, general secretary of the National Postgraduate Committee (NPC), an independent charity that represents postgraduate students. "Science and technology in particular has a lot of money and as long as you have a good undergraduate degree, you're realistic and you play the game, you'll get funding."

Take on the competition

The British government invests £2.8 billion in research each year - enough to buy roughly 6 billion Petri dishes. This money is passed to seven councils that disseminate it to the nation's research institutions. "We allocate funding through a highly competitive process," explains Ian Lyne, head of postgraduate training at the Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC). "If a department holds our funding it's a hallmark of quality."

To get your postgraduate paws on some of that money, students must approach a well-funded department directly - along with all the other hopefuls. In 2006/2007 the School of Mathematics at the University of Manchester enrolled 39 PhD students out of nearly 150 applicants. "If you want funding it's very competitive," says Professor Paul Glendinning, head of the department. He advises students not to blow hot and cold. "Keep us in the loop with what you're doing. If we're met by silence at some point we're going to assume the person isn't interested any longer."

Do it for charity

Many postgraduate research positions are sponsored by charities. The Wellcome Trust, the UK's largest medical charity, recently promised an extra £137 million in four-year PhD programmes over the next nine years, so there's plenty of money floating around.

Charity funding carries different responsibilities and experiences from public funding, particularly if the money comes from a small organisation. "It's very much a community," says Selina Wray, whose PhD is funded by the Progressive Supranuclear Palsy Association. "You meet people who have a personal connection to the disease - this helps to maintain a focus on why you are doing the research. It makes you more determined to work hard." Wray says the biggest difference about being funded by a charity is the necessity for good communication. "People from the charity come along to conferences and are genuinely interested to hear about your work. It's important that the fund-raisers understand what is going on with their money," she explains.

Tick the right boxes

A bewildering array of grants and scholarships are available for further study in the UK. Often these have very specific requirements, and it's worth carrying out some research to see if you fit anyone's criteria. If you can demonstrate a special interest in weaving or woven textiles, for example, you could receive a £1500 donation from the Worshipful Company of Weavers; provide evidence that your course is relevant to the activities of the Milford Haven Port Authority and you could receive a £2000 scholarship from them. With a typical master's costing around £3000, these sums represent a significant potential contribution towards your studies.

Ask the boss

If you are already employed, consider taking the boss out for lunch and asking whether they'll fund your course. "Most businesses will want some assurances in return for their investment," says Simon Briault of the Federation of Small Businesses. "For example, a prospective student could have to agree terms which state that on successful completion they will stay in the business for a certain amount of time or pay back a certain percentage of the fee." Convince them you're worth investing in and you might find yourself a sponsor.

Hit the road

If the cost of studying in the UK is troubling you, then it might be time for a change of scenery. And where better to seek inspiration than the home of the Nobel prize? Higher education in Sweden is fully subsidised by the state, and even foreign students are entitled to study for free. What's more, with more than 450 master's courses taught entirely in English, you won't even have to learn a new language.

Be industrious

"I'd definitely encourage postgraduates to consider seeking industry sponsorship," says Claire McAleer, who is working towards an engineering doctorate at the University of Southampton. Funding for McAleer's studies comes largely from Rolls-Royce, where she spends much of her time working on ways to reduce the noise emitted by aircraft engines. "It's much more interactive than a typical PhD," she says. "You get to see how your research applies in an industrial context and how it's useful in the real world." Combining university education with industry placements can also give you valuable experience of the business world. "It opens a lot of doors for the future," says McAleer.

Get a loan

The prospect of more debt might bring you out in a sweat, but a career development loan (CDL) - offered by Barclays, the Royal Bank of Scotland and the Co-operative Bank - is an option to consider. You can borrow between £300 and £8000, and the Learning and Skills Council will pay the interest on the loan until a month after you have finished studying.

"If you are up to standard and can realistically do the course then yes, I would advise taking out a CDL," says Duncan Connors of the NPC, but he urges prospective students to think carefully. "I would not use a loan if you don't have a defined career outcome, because all that's going to happen is you'll get into thousands of pounds' worth of debt."

Don't be parted from work

If you've been gainfully employed since leaving university, you could be reluctant to reinstate beans on toast as your main meal of the day. Part-time courses offer a compromise, allowing students to earn while they study.

"I wanted to carry on studying but didn't want to leave my job," explains Carol Boags, a teaching lab manager at the University of East Anglia. She continued to work full-time, devoting evenings and weekends towards studying for an MSc with the Open University. Boags estimates that her studies took up some 20 hours a week which, she warns, is a commitment not to be taken lightly. "You've got to be dedicated and a good time-manager to take up distance learning," she says, "but it's a good experience and I would certainly recommend it."

And if all else fails...

"Think outside the box," says Alex Tew, who earned a cool million during his studies. Dreading the thought of university debt, Tew invented the Million Dollar Homepage, selling individual pixels on his website to advertisers for $1 each. "Within three or four weeks of launching the site I'd covered the average student debt," he says. "Most postgraduate students will have knowledge of a very specific area and probably some interesting insights into their own subject." Tew recommends using this inside information to make some money. "Get thinking about ideas and if you think you've got a good [moneyspinning] one, go and do it," he advises. "Look at Sergey Brin and Larry Page - they were IT postgraduates, and Google was born out of their research."


Top Tips

"Applicants need to be able to communicate and explain science to a lay person. We want our researchers to be ambassadors."
Ayesha Kahn, scientific liaison officer, Alzheimer's Society

"Get advice from people in your university department. It's very important to demystify the funding process."
Ian Lyne, head of postgraduate training at the BBSRC

"Postgraduates have got the analytical ability, basic probability and maths skills - so why not try online poker?"
Jerome Bradpiece won over £30,000 as a University of Oxford philosophy student


Case study: Going the extra mile

Sabine Bahn is director of the Centre for Neuropsychiatric Research at the University of Cambridge. The department has around £4 million of funds including a recent £2.5 million grant awarded by the Stanley Medical Research Institute, a US-based charity.

Despite such generous funding, much of which is for postgraduate studies, Bahn says the battle for research positions in her laboratory is very competitive. "I get up to 10 applications a week even without advertising. If I advertise I get hundreds."

When she's faced with so many candidates, it's enthusiasm that makes one applicant stand out from the rest, says Bahn. "I'm not so interested in their CVs to be quite honest," she admits. "They have to have read about what we've been doing and thought about it carefully. And most importantly, they have to have common sense and a clear idea about where they want to go."

"I like those who want to prove themselves and be given a chance," she says. True to her word, Bahn currently funds Yishai Levin who, despite having "mediocre" grades and no research background, spent the time and money to fly over from Israel to convince her in person that he could bring new skills to her team. "In such a large group I haven't got time to do too much hand-holding so I need people who are self-motivated and can think independently."


David Brill is a science and medicine journalist based in London

Thursday, January 29, 2009

In a bad way: men's health in the papers

Press Gazette 3rd August 2007

This article, along with a commentary, was also reproduced by the Men's Health Forum

Statistics suggest men are in worse health than women - yet coverage of male health issues is a low priority in the national press. Medical journalist David Brill believes men deserve more column inches devoted to their well-being

I know three things. I know that I’m supposed to examine my testicles in the shower every now and then; I know that cranberry juice is good for my prostate, although I’m not sure exactly where that is or what it does; and I also know that high cholesterol is a bad thing.

Why, as a young, active, well-read man, is this the extent of my knowledge of men’s health?
The newspapers are full of Herceptin, IVF and HRT. Soaring abortion rates and teenage pregnancies make for regular headline material.

Yet statistics suggest that men have worse health than women. The average man in the UK is more likely to smoke, be obese, and to drink above the recommended alcohol intake than the average woman. He is three times more likely to commit suicide than his female counterpart, and can expect to die five years younger.

Faced with such gloomy figures, one might expect men’s health to receive more coverage than women’s. But a study of the Daily Mail’s health pages reveals a different picture.

The newspaper devotes significant coverage to health-related topics, and carries a dedicated weekly section. With such a large volume of articles, it was a natural candidate for a postgraduate research project to investigate the balance between newspaper coverage of men’s and women’s health issues.

Taking a yearly snapshot (mid-June to mid-July), around 900 health articles were published in the newspaper between 2001 and 2006. While most of these did not relate to either sex in particular, some 34 per cent dealt specifically with women’s health, compared with about 8 per cent for men’s health. Furthermore, men’s health stories were, on average, three pages further back in the newspaper than women’s.

'I don’t think that men get the attention they deserve on the health pages,' says Barbara Lantin, a freelance health writer who in 2006 was named Patient’s Association Health Journalist of the Year. 'A lot of stories are female-focused and men’s health seems to be rather marginalised.'

This is a sentiment apparently shared by many journalists, yet the issue of gender bias within media health coverage remains largely unexplored from an academic perspective.

But maybe journalists aren't to blame for this discrepancy. Do men actually want to read about their health? Men under the age of 45 make half as many visits to their GP as women.

Department of Health figures show that 13 times as many women as men participated in the first year of the National Chlamydia Screening Programme, despite the disease being equally prevalent in both sexes. Perhaps men are simply less interested in health issues than women.

'I think the perception is that the readership of health pages is female, and that wives, partners or mothers are the ones that tell their men-folk to go off and do healthy things,' explains Lantin.
'I suppose, therefore, that if you run men’s health stories you might expect it to be the women that read them and urge the men to look after their own health.'

This sentiment appears to be supported by my study of the Daily Mail. In 2002, the paper featured a four-page special on men’s health. Yet the target readership of this section becomes clear from the headline on a full-page article: "MOT your man: 15 health questions every woman should ask – it might save your partner’s life."

The coverage of men’s health in the national press is likely to be a changing picture. No obvious patterns emerged over the six-year study period, but Peter Baker, a former journalist and the director of the Men’s Health Forum – a charity that aims to improve awareness of men’s health issues – thinks that men’s health could be a subject in decline.

'Before the mid 1980s, when glossy men’s magazines came out, there was not much men’s health coverage. It probably peaked around ten years ago, with the arrival of Viagra,' he explains. 'Back then, it was quite new and there was an increasing demand for it. It’s not as new and sexy now. Publishers realised that sales were in writing about beer and sex, not health.

'One of the crucial issue is that men just don’t like asking for help about anything, or to be seen not to know the answer. And that includes health. I think that, broadly speaking, men are much more interested than we would imagine, but are just more private about it. I think newspapers are letting their readers down by not covering these issues more seriously and more substantially.'

No single paper can be considered representative of the whole national press, yet it is likely that the Daily Mail reflects a wider trend, where men’s health is given less priority than women’s. But surely it is just a matter of time until men demand to know more about their well-being. Maybe one day testicular cancer will grab the headlines, and I might just find out what my prostate does after all.

David Brill is assistant editor of Nature Clinical Practice Cardiovascular Medicine

Monday, January 19, 2009

Where have all the aspen gone?

Nature News 2nd October 2006
Link

David Brill talks to forestry expert Wayne Shepperd, at the Rocky Mountain Research Station at Fort Collins, Colorado, about the mysterious death of these trees in the western United States.

There have long been stories about decling aspen numbers, but you've now realised things have been much worse over the past few years. What is happening?

Aspen here in the western United States regenerate by sprouting from the root system of existing trees, rather than growing from seeds.

Please follow the article link to continue reading.

Mouse brain map is complete

Nature 27th September 2006
Link
David Brill

Gene expression database goes online

Three years, 21,000 genes and US$41 million after the Allen Brain Atlas was begun, it is finished. A three-dimensional map of gene expression in the mouse brain, the atlas is the most comprehensive study of its kind to date.

Please follow the article link to continue reading.

Socialites need more sleep

Nature News 18th September 2006
Link
David Brill

Flies with a busy social life take longer naps.

A hectic social life makes a fruitfly take longer naps, according to a new study. This seemingly simple finding could prove important in helping to understand why we sleep, and what effect socializing has on our brain circuitry.

Please follow the article link to continue reading.

First tree joins genome club

Nature News 11th September 2006
Link
David Brill

Poplar sequence could help to turn trees into better fuels.

The first tree genome has been published. Armed with this information about the black cottonwood poplar (Populus trichocarpa), researchers hope they will be able to make the tree a better source of renewable energy.

Please follow the article link to continue reading.

Neanderthal's last stand

Nature News 11th September 2006
Link
David Brill

Cave in Gibraltar may be most recent home of extinct species.

Gibraltar may have been the last refuge of the Neanderthals, according to the results of a six-year archaeological dig.

The findings, which show that Neanderthals lived alongside modern humans for thousands of years, bring fresh evidence to the debate on what happened to our evolutionary cousins, and whether modern humans drove them to extinction.

Please follow the article link to continue reading.